Home Battenfeld The Best Home Battery for a Net Zero Home?

The Best Home Battery for a Net Zero Home?

34
45

The Best Home Battery for a Net Zero Home? Use code UNDECIDED50 to get 50% OFF your first Factor box plus 20% off your next month at The number of whole home battery options out there can make your head spin – it’s a real charge to the senses. Everywhere I looked at CES this past January someone had a shocking, modular, whole-home battery solution. Well, I’ve made my decision … or rather, I made my decision a while ago and just recently got out of permitting hell to have it finally installed. I ended up installing an Enphase battery system, but not for the reasons you might think. So why did I go with Enphase? What took so long? And most importantly … is it going to be worth the cost?

Watch Tesla Solar Roof vs Solar Panels: Which is Worth It?

Video script and citations:

Check out the mentioned video Are solar panels worth it in 2024?

Get my achieve energy security with solar guide:

Follow-up podcast:
Video version –
Audio version –

Join the Undecided Discord server:

👋 Support Undecided on Patreon!

⚙️ Gear & Products I Like

Visit my Energysage Portal (US):
Research solar panels and get quotes for free!

And find heat pump installers near you (US):

Or find community solar near you (US):

For a curated solar buying experience (Canada)
EnergyPal’s free personalized quotes:

Tesla Referral Code:
Get 1,000 free supercharging miles
or a discount on Tesla Solar & Powerwalls

👉 Follow Me
Mastodon

X

Mastodon

Instagram

Facebook

Website

📺 YouTube Tools I Recommend
Audio file(s) provided by Epidemic Sound

TubeBuddy

VidIQ

I may earn a small commission for my endorsement or recommendation to products or services linked above, but I wouldn’t put them here if I didn’t like them. Your purchase helps support the channel and the videos I produce. Thank you.

00:00 – Intro
00:50 – What Did I Get?
01:40 – Why This Battery … or Any Battery?
05:05 – What Did it Cost?
08:07 – What About The Pros & Cons?
11:31 – What Would I Have Done Differently?

Note to readers: Please click the share buttons above or below. Forward this article to your email lists. Crosspost on your blog site, social media, internet forums. etc.

45 COMMENTS

  1. I can’t get over that price tag of $33,000. That’s completely outrageous for the hyper majority of people. That’s almost double what I paid for a used model S in February for 1/5th the capacity and 6 months of bureaucratic hell. Yes, I know “location, location, location” but be honest Matt, you know that’s a ridiculous price for most people even if it may be average for your area

  2. 5KWh storage is equivalent to 1Kg wood in thermal energy. So literary any (fairly small) branch of wood found in the forest has 5-10x (thermal) storage capacity of these expensive batteries, given efficient burning process. To con vert to electric one needs a high efficient thermodynamic transformer – a boundary layer turbine, and a small 2.5-5KW permanent magnet motor/generator.

  3. How many days can these batteries power your house when there is a storm outage? Ignore EV charging because you can drive to a supercharger. Living in Massachusetts, I’ve had power outages for 3-4 days, requiring a generator.

  4. I had the interesting experience of trying to clean my solar panels the other day. It became extremely dangerous and I started slipping off my roof when it became wet. I won’t be trying that again. I wonder if this is factored into people’s calculations when deciding to go solar or how to design the panel access. I would imagine the cost of having someone clean the panels every 6 months would have a great effect on their cost effectiveness. I’m surprised no one seems to design a safe way to access the panels on the roof.

  5. A Hyundai Ioniq 5 has up to 77 kWh and can output 3.6 kW with V2L… so, if you anyway have an electric car in your garage that's usually kept at 80% you have as much battery as 12 of those units in an emergency… how often does your household need 12 kW output?

    What you need is just enough batteries to run your fridge etc. And enough capacity to fill up with solar while your car isn't at home.

    In other words, I think you're buying too many small batteries at a too high price if your vehicle is already electric. Spend the money on control circuits instead.

  6. Here in the Netherlands the company homewizard advertised with a battery that is just plugged into a wall outlet. Stackable. Very interesting. €1395 2.7 kWh 800 watt. No extra costs just plug it in.

  7. As you mentioned, the prices in Europe are significantly cheaper. One such module is offered for 3500 € installed by the company who installed my solar panels 4 years ago, with Enphase inverters, so it will be plug and play.

  8. I hate my enphase system. The setup process is a huge pain constantly waiting for microinverters to provision and 3 out of 4 of my microinverters stopped outputting power. I should have just bought a cheap Chinese grid tie inverter.

  9. 12:08 That's insane for LFP. Even more insane when you consider how a Lithium Ion fire burns AKA that a sprinkler system above it would likely not do anything in the extremely unlikely event you did have a battery fire. Did the fossil fuel industry bribe your local gov't for that? Or perhaps a local gas/diesel generator company?

  10. Mandatory sprinklers for battery backup in the garage, but no mandatory sprinklers for the 15 gallons of gasoline in the average person's average gas tank. That's over 500kWh of potential (flammable and explosive) energy, compared to the puny 60kWhs in the Tesla…

  11. @UndecidedWithMattFerrell

    Matt, I have serious concerns about the safety of lithium based batteries, regardless of chemistry. There are alternatives. What are your thoughts on those alternatives and why didn't you go for one of them?

  12. Hey Matt, how do you suggest condo owners should setup solar? Apart from cost, as there are space and grid regulations, is going through the hassle even worth it? Appreciate the detail in your videos

  13. I ended up getting the Enphase 5ps as well. Well, still in permitting hell. Been 3 months already.

    Thought really hard about EcoFlow but ultimately decided to stay within the Enphase ecosystem. There's a big software component to these systems nowadays and Enphase is a bit more mature in that space (vs say, Anker or Ecoflow who could abandon their app anytime).

    Also looked into Span. My installer strongly discouraged it. Thanks for sharing your thoughts about that, sounds like not getting Span was a good call.

  14. Those batteries wouldn’t last 24 hours in a storm event. A generator with 2×120 gallon LP tanks can last 4-5 days on a 3,000 sqft house in summer. This isn’t even close for a backup power solution. This does provide continuity of power for a while.

  15. HAHAHA you lost me at $33k beyond the solar panels. I hadn't even thought of this but you're better off buying a storage tank and having a generator.
    you say "waiting for a part" as if these companies would supply repair parts to consumers lol
    right to repair is a myth outside of ICE vehicles and even there it's getting phased out

  16. Kind of ironic that a company that is know for turning DC solar into AC right at the panel would have a battery solution which by definition is DC. Wonder if there's a microinverter like solution that doesn't need microinverters, like pulling a separate wire from each solar panel to conditioner all the MPPT tracking while in DC to charge up your batteries, then just use a regular inverter to convert it back to AC power. Sure there's a lot more wires to pull since each panel needs a wire, but that's gotta be cheaper than (at least equipment wise) than microinverter for each panel, then multiple inverters at the battery to convert back to DC.

    Oh and do you need to connect to the grid to get those rebates? I would think being part of the virtual power grid would end up costing you more money in the long run because your VERY EXPENSIVE batteries won't last as long.

  17. The chain dragging on EV uptake is still lack of home charging ability for so many. Have your own driveway, EVs are a no brainer if you're buying new.

    My mum lives in a popular restaurant precinct without off-street parking. She regularly has to park up to a block away from her own house. So despite owning her home and having a moderate sized solar system, she can't use it to charge her car.

    There is only 1 Tesla supercharger in the whole of the Australian state of Tasmania!

    Until this issue is solved, EV uptake will struggle to get beyond a certain percentage, and I am a massive EV convert.

Leave a Reply